• Home
  • Contact
  • SHOP
    • HANDCRAFTED – Home Décor, Accessories, Candles, Jewelry, Gifts and more!
    • PRINTED – Clothing, Puzzles, Home Décor, Fashion Accessories, and more!
  • Disclosures & Policies
    • Privacy Policy
    • Advertising Disclosure
    • Cookie Policy
    • Terms of Use

Me and Annabel Lee

Goth-It-Yourself Tutorials, Twisted Holiday Ideas, Macabre Parties, Spooky Recipes, Wicked Wedding Details, Dark & Unusual Must-Have Shopping Lists and so much more…

  • Home
  • GOTH IT YOURSELF
  • EERIE EDIBLES
  • SINFUL CELEBRATIONS
    • All Hallows Eve
    • Til Death Do Us Part
    • St Valentine’s Day Massacre
    • Dreaming of a Dark Christmas
  • DARK TABLESCAPES
  • DEVILISH MUST-HAVES

Butterfinger Cream Cheese Spread

October 26, 2016 Alexandra Leave a Comment

Butterfinger Cream Cheese Spread - Looking for something to do with that leftover Halloween Candy? Try this sweet spread! www.MeandAnnabelLee.comIt’s that time again…. my cream cheese flavor of the month for October!  This month I was inspired by Halloween!  No… not by Pumpkins… like ALL of the food I see everywhere in October, but instead…..  Halloween Candy!!  This month’s flavor is Butterfinger!

Butterfinger Cream Cheese Spread - Looking for something to do with that leftover Halloween Candy? Try this sweet spread! www.MeandAnnabelLee.com

First, let your cream cheese sit out until softened.  Meanwhile, lightly crush those candy bars…  I used a wooden spoon to crush mine…. great tension release!!  I didn’t go crazy pounding them into dust…. my electric mixer does a good job of breaking them up, and besides.. I liked the idea of having some small chunks of candy bar in the spread.  Mix the candy bar, cream cheese, and peanut butter  until thoroughly blended.  Chill for at least an hour.  The flavors get stronger with age! 🙂  Keep refrigerated until ready to serve.  Besides bagels, this spread works great on graham crackers as a quick snack, or paired with apples for a crunchy twist!Butterfinger Cream Cheese Spread - Looking for something to do with that leftover Halloween Candy? Try this sweet spread! www.MeandAnnabelLee.com

Check out last month’s Cream Cheese Spread flavor….  Olive Pimento Cream Cheese Spread.

Butterfinger Cream Cheese Spread
 
Save Print
Prep time
6 mins
Total time
6 mins
 
Try this sweet cream cheese spread on your favorite bagel, cracker, or piece of fruit!
Author: Alexandra
Serves: 10 oz
Ingredients
  • 8 oz cream cheese - softened
  • 2 full size Butterfinger candy bars
  • 1 teaspoon creamy peanut butter
Instructions
  1. Crush the Candy Bars
  2. Mix all ingredients
  3. Chill
  4. Serve
3.5.3217

 

More Posts You May Like
Filter by
Post Page
St Valentine's Day Massacre EERIE EDIBLES GOTH IT YOURSELF Edible Favorites All Hallows Eve DARK TABLESCAPES DIY Favorites
Sort by

Bugs, Bones & Chocolate

2026-02-05

10

Gothic Plant Stand Makeover: From Trash to Treasure

2025-07-16

10

Five Black Cylinder Shaped Tea Tins, each with a different Victorian Gothic Style Label... One tin is on its side with loose tea spilling out of it.

Tales From the Tin

2025-04-29

10

Bring some Halloween inspiration into your Spring Décor this year with these DIY Gothic Decoupage Eggs | Transform Plastic Easter Eggs into Gothic Spring Décor with this easy and inexpensive project using Halloween inspired Stamps | Skulls, Bats, Ravens, Spiderwebs | A SpringOWeen Goth It Yourself Project | Me and Annabel Lee Blog

Spring Into Action

2021-03-31

10

No Bake Bleeding Heart Oreo Cookie Cake | A Macabre Dessert for your Gothic Valentine or Anti Valentine’s Day | Anatomical Human Heart Cake Art | Me and Annabel Lee

Bleeding Heart

2020-02-06

10

How to create a haunting yet luxurious Halloween Dinner Party fit for a Skull King or Queen… Burgundy Silk Velvet Table Runner, Antique Gold Candelabras, chunky gold candlesticks, Black Candles, Bowls of Dark Fruits, Black Velvet Linens, Gothic Black Glass Goblets, and Black and Gold Skulls wearing crowns | Me and Annabel Lee Blog

The Royal Treatment

2019-10-30

10

DIY Creepy Hand Wall Sconce Candle Holder – Transform a Fake Hand from Halloween Decoration to Gothic Home Décor with this makeover….. Patina Copper, Wicked fingernails, Birdcage Candle Holder | Me and Annabel Lee Blog

Come Here My Pretty

2019-10-02

10

Victorian Gentleman Skeleton Chalkboard Sign and Figurine - How to transform a Halloween Decoration into year round Gothic Home Decor… Menu Board, Halloween Wedding Sign, To do List, and much more| Me and Annabel Lee Blog

Gentleman Caller

2019-08-15

10

Create these Gothic Antique Bird Feet Candlesticks from resin Halloween décor | Full tutorial on how to make fake Halloween decorations look like real home decor by adding a rusted antique finish | Me and Annabel Lee Blog

Standing On Your Own Two Feet

2019-07-24

10

Archived Content Bagel, Butterfinger, flavored cream cheese

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Looking for something?

Popular DIYs

DIY Creepy Hand Wall Sconce Candle Holder – Transform a Fake Hand from Halloween Decoration to Gothic Home Décor with this makeover….. Patina Copper, Wicked fingernails, Birdcage Candle Holder | Me and Annabel Lee Blog

Come Here My Pretty

DIY Skull Decoupage Flower Pots | Outdoor Mod Podge | www.MeandAnnabelLee.com

How Does Your Garden Grow?

5 Easy Ideas for DIY Crystal Balls | Faux Mercury Glass Tutorial | Halloween Crafts and Decorations | Witches Dinner Party Table Setting | Pagan Fortune Telling | Gazing Balls |www.MeandAnnabelLee.com

Crystal Visions

Create these Gothic Antique Bird Feet Candlesticks from resin Halloween décor | Full tutorial on how to make fake Halloween decorations look like real home decor by adding a rusted antique finish | Me and Annabel Lee Blog

Standing On Your Own Two Feet

DIY Snake Cake Stand | Black and Gold Serpent Dessert Display Pedestal | Poisonous Apple | Halloween Decor Crafts | www.MeandAnnabelLee.com

Lead Us To Temptation

DIY Gothic Upholstered Skull Memo Board | Skull Clay Mold | Ruby Rub 'n Buff | www.MeandAnnabelLee.com

Not Too Shabby!

Growing Old Gracefully

Victorian Gothic Image Transfer | DIY Vintage Vampire Bat TV Tray Table | Goth It Yourself | Silhouette Sticker Paper | Wallpaper projects | www.MeandAnnabelLee.com

A Vintage Bat

Archives

More Recent Posts

Preserved Spider Web Art - How to preserve a real cobweb - Gothic Home Decor - Ornate Gold frames
Five Black Cylinder Shaped Tea Tins, each with a different Victorian Gothic Style Label... One tin is on its side with loose tea spilling out of it.
DIY Black Victorian Gothic Eggs | Transform Easter Eggs into Gothic Spring Décor using Halloween Images and Victorian Frame Molds| Black Easter Eggs | A Spring-O-Ween Goth It Yourself Project | Creepster | Gothic Skull & Roses | The Raven | Me and Annabel Lee Blog
Bring some Halloween inspiration into your Spring Décor this year with these DIY Gothic Decoupage Eggs | Transform Plastic Easter Eggs into Gothic Spring Décor with this easy and inexpensive project using Halloween inspired Stamps | Skulls, Bats, Ravens, Spiderwebs | A SpringOWeen Goth It Yourself Project | Me and Annabel Lee Blog
ark & Curious Valentine Gift Guide | Dark, Curious, Gothic, and Unusual Valentine Gifts | Valentine’s and Anti-Valentine Day | Human Hearts, Red Skulls, Black Roses, Skeleton Lovers, Gothic Literature, Horror Films, Tarot, Fetish | Dark Home Décor | Gothic Jewelry and Fashion | Me and Annabel Lee
How to make a DIY Tiered Raven Halloween Serving Tray | Goth it Yourself Edgar Allan Poe inspired server | Dessert Stand | Gothic Entertaining | The Raven Halloween Craft | Me and Annabel Lee Blog

Copyright © 2026 · Daily Dish Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

 

Loading Comments...
 

    We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.