• Home
  • Contact
  • SHOP
    • HANDCRAFTED – Home Décor, Accessories, Candles, Jewelry, Gifts and more!
    • PRINTED – Clothing, Puzzles, Home Décor, Fashion Accessories, and more!
  • Disclosures & Policies
    • Privacy Policy
    • Advertising Disclosure
    • Cookie Policy
    • Terms of Use

Me and Annabel Lee

Goth-It-Yourself Tutorials, Twisted Holiday Ideas, Macabre Parties, Spooky Recipes, Wicked Wedding Details, Dark & Unusual Must-Have Shopping Lists and so much more…

  • Home
  • GOTH IT YOURSELF
  • EERIE EDIBLES
  • SINFUL CELEBRATIONS
    • All Hallows Eve
    • Til Death Do Us Part
    • St Valentine’s Day Massacre
    • Dreaming of a Dark Christmas
  • DARK TABLESCAPES
  • DEVILISH MUST-HAVES

The Curse of the Pumpkin Bread

November 9, 2017 Alexandra 6 Comments

Cursed Pumpkin Bread | Thanksgiving Menu | Fall Baking | www.MeandAnnabelLee.com

Cursed Pumpkin Bread Recipe | Thanksgiving Menu | Fall Baking | www.MeandAnnabelLee.com

This is a tale of a Pumpkin Bread.  A family recipe passed down with hesitation.  Because this is no ordinary Pumpkin Bread… this is a cursed Pumpkin Bread!

It all started in the early 70’s.  My mom came up with a recipe for Pumpkin Bread, and baked it for a ski trip she and my dad were going on.  They were driving one car while another two friends drove in a separate car.  A half hour into the road trip, they experienced unexpected car trouble.  They were forced to turn around, and bring the car to a shop to be fixed.  Instead of ruining their ski weekend, their friends offered them a ride.  My mom and dad packed their belongings, and the Pumpkin Bread, into their friend’s car and took off.  Yet again… more unexpected car trouble.  Despite their friends’ car having just gotten a check up right before the trip, the oil cap popped off, and oil went everywhere! They were using windshield wipers to try to see through the front oil covered window!  Needless to say, the ski trip was canceled.  For years, my parents had been going on that particular ski trip, and had never experienced any issues until then.  What was different this time?  The Pumpkin Bread.  While it may have started as a comical suggestion… I mean, why would Pumpkin Bread cause car trouble?!….. they became convinced it was related.

Cursed Pumpkin Bread | Thanksgiving Menu | Fall Baking | www.MeandAnnabelLee.comI know… sounds like a bit of a stretch….  But let’s fast forward a couple of years.  My mom decides enough time has passed to give the bread another try… She made a loaf, packed it up, and they headed for the beach on the Jersey shore.  Car trouble.  No beach trip.

For years my mom continued to make the very popular Pumpkin Bread, but refused to travel with it.  Years went by, and eventually my parents were driving through Virginia on their way to New Jersey for the holidays.  My mom reluctantly agreed to bring her pumpkin bread.  After all, it is the perfect Thanksgiving baked good!  Do I really need to say what happened?  The car trouble was so bad they had to leave the car in Virginia while my mom’s father drove six hours to rescue them.

Cursed Pumpkin Bread | Thanksgiving Menu | Fall Baking | www.MeandAnnabelLee.comThree time’s a charm.  My parents refused to ever travel with the bread again.  Various friends and family have even recounted stories of car trouble after making the bread, and bringing it along somewhere.  And until now, I’ve never even attempted to make it.  Wasn’t worth the risk.  But recently I came across my mom’s now famously cursed Pumpkin Bread recipe.  It was calling my name!  But, no – I will not be traveling with it…. just enjoying it with a nice cup of tea in front of a fire, in the comfort of my living room!

Cursed Pumpkin Bread | Thanksgiving Menu | Fall Baking | www.MeandAnnabelLee.comSo.. now it’s up to you…  Do you have the guts to make this bread and find out if the curse is still alive?  Conveniently, the recipe makes two loaves.  One for you and one to share… if you dare!

Looking for some more Fall flavored goodness.  This Apple Sangria is the perfect Fall cocktail!  And this Jack O Lantern Pumpkin Spiced Rum Cake is a decadent dessert!

Maybe you’re just a fan of pumpkins… then you shouldn’t spend another minute without the DIY Pumpkin Wine Dispenser!

Cursed Pumpkin Bread | Thanksgiving Menu | Fall Baking | www.MeandAnnabelLee.com

Cursed Pumpkin Bread
 
Save Print
Cook time
1 hour 10 mins
Total time
1 hour 10 mins
 
Do you dare? Make this Pumpkin Bread and enjoy every bite.. but travel with it and pay the price!! Will you take the risk?
Author: Alexandra
Cuisine: Bread
Serves: 2 loaves
Ingredients
  • 3½ cups Flour
  • 3 cups Sugar
  • 2 tsp Baking soda
  • 2 tsp Cinnamon
  • 1 tsp Salt
  • 1 tsp Nutmeg
  • ½ tsp Cloves
  • 1 15oz can Pumpkin
  • 2 Eggs beaten
  • ⅔ cups Water
  • 1 cup Melted Butter
  • Optional Dry Ingredient:
  • ½ cup raisins and/or chopped nuts
Instructions
  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees
  2. Combine all dry ingredients
  3. Create a well in the center of the dry ingredients, set aside
  4. In a small bowl, combine Pumpkin, Egg, and Water
  5. Pour Melted Butter, and Liquid Ingredients into the well of the Dry Ingredients
  6. Gently Mix
  7. Grease/Flour 2 Loaf Pans
  8. Pour Mix into loaf pans, and Bake for 1 hour, 10 minutes
3.5.3228

More Posts You May Like
Filter by
Post Page
GOTH IT YOURSELF All Hallows Eve DEVILISH MUST-HAVES More to Explore DARK TABLESCAPES Dreaming of a Dark Christmas EERIE EDIBLES DIY Favorites SINFUL CELEBRATIONS
Sort by

A Stake in the Ground!

2025-10-24

10

Jack-O’-Lantern Glow Up

2025-10-09

10

Coloring Books with a Dark Twist

2025-08-01

10

Five Black Cylinder Shaped Tea Tins, each with a different Victorian Gothic Style Label... One tin is on its side with loose tea spilling out of it.

Tales From the Tin

2025-04-29

10

How to create a haunting yet elegant Fall Table for your Thanksgiving Dinner Party… A mix of black velvet, faux fur, antique gold, black candles, candelabras, black pumpkins and gilded in gold touches of Fall to create this Black and Gold Gothic Thanksgiving Table design | Me and Annabel Lee Blog

Fall into Black and Gold

2019-11-21

10

15 Dark, Twisted, & Gothic Ugly Christmas Sweaters Shopping Guide | Skulls, Krampus, Horror Movies, Occult, Heavy Metal, Halloween, and more | Holiday Apparel for your Creepmas Party | Me and Annabel Lee Blog

Ugly Christmas Sweaters with a Dark Twist, 2019 Edition

2019-11-12

10

Pumpkin Fondue …. Classic Cheese Fondue with a Pumpkin Twist | Fall Recipes | An appetizer for your Thanksgiving or Halloween Dinner Party | Serve in a Cauldron, a Black Cast Iron Pumpkin Cocotte, or a Knucklehead Pumpkin to add a dark edge to the presentation | Me and Annabel Lee Blog

The Big Cheese

2019-11-06

10

Standing On Your Own Two Feet

2019-07-24

10

Black and Purple Gothic Thanksgiving Table Decor | Add a touch of Halloween to your Thanksgiving Spread | Fall Tablescape | Black Pumpkins | Plum Velvet Runner | Mercury Glass | Candlelit Dinner | www.MeandAnnabelLee.com

Plum Crazy

2018-11-07

10

EERIE EDIBLES bread, cursed, Fall, gothic baking, gothic martha stewart, pumpkin, Thanksgiving

Comments

  1. Sue says

    November 10, 2017 at 9:14 am

    Yep, totally been in that situation… more than once! lol I shall look forward to next week’s post, my friend x

    Reply
    • Alexandra says

      November 10, 2017 at 9:38 am

      It’s the worst! After completely scrapping round one, and starting over from scratch … I made it all the way to the end of the project. I sealed it, and the sealer I used had a bad reaction! I wanted to punch someone! I think I have a solution! Wish me luck this weekend!! 🙂

      Reply
  2. Sue says

    November 10, 2017 at 9:17 am

    P.S. I am totally too much of a woos to try making the pumpkin bread!

    Reply
    • Alexandra says

      November 10, 2017 at 9:40 am

      Too funny! I know!! The recipe makes two loaves, which I can never eat by myself. I tried to think who I could give the other one to, but I seriously refuse to put that thing in my car even to drive to a neighbor’s house! In the freezer it went!! 🙂

      Reply
  3. Kimberly Albertson says

    November 22, 2019 at 10:15 am

    For me, it’s a Duran Duran t-shirt. The first time, a friend and I were driving to LA to see the band and ended up spending New Year’s weekend in a truck-stop town while waiting for an alternator to come in and missed the concert. The 2nd time, another trip to LA, and we needed to replace my friend’s fuel pump.

    I’m not allowed to wear that shirt anymore on any road trips.

    Reply
    • Alexandra says

      November 27, 2019 at 1:57 am

      Funny story Kimberly!! Note to self… the perfect gift for our enemies… Pumpkin Bread wrapped in a Duran Duran T-shirt! 🙂

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Looking for something?

Popular DIYs

Growing Old Gracefully

DIY Gothic Upholstered Skull Memo Board | Skull Clay Mold | Ruby Rub 'n Buff | www.MeandAnnabelLee.com

Not Too Shabby!

DIY Creepy Hand Wall Sconce Candle Holder – Transform a Fake Hand from Halloween Decoration to Gothic Home Décor with this makeover….. Patina Copper, Wicked fingernails, Birdcage Candle Holder | Me and Annabel Lee Blog

Come Here My Pretty

How Does Your Garden Grow?

5 Easy Ideas for DIY Crystal Balls | Faux Mercury Glass Tutorial | Halloween Crafts and Decorations | Witches Dinner Party Table Setting | Pagan Fortune Telling | Gazing Balls |www.MeandAnnabelLee.com

Crystal Visions

DIY Snake Cake Stand | Black and Gold Serpent Dessert Display Pedestal | Poisonous Apple | Halloween Decor Crafts | www.MeandAnnabelLee.com

Lead Us To Temptation

Standing On Your Own Two Feet

Victorian Gothic Image Transfer | DIY Vintage Vampire Bat TV Tray Table | Goth It Yourself | Silhouette Sticker Paper | Wallpaper projects | www.MeandAnnabelLee.com

A Vintage Bat

Archives

Popular Posts

Shelf Life
Crystal Visions
Warm Your Bones
Drink Up Witches
Twenty Four Karat Black Martini

More Recent Posts

Preserved Spider Web Art - How to preserve a real cobweb - Gothic Home Decor - Ornate Gold frames
Five Black Cylinder Shaped Tea Tins, each with a different Victorian Gothic Style Label... One tin is on its side with loose tea spilling out of it.
DIY Black Victorian Gothic Eggs | Transform Easter Eggs into Gothic Spring Décor using Halloween Images and Victorian Frame Molds| Black Easter Eggs | A Spring-O-Ween Goth It Yourself Project | Creepster | Gothic Skull & Roses | The Raven | Me and Annabel Lee Blog
ark & Curious Valentine Gift Guide | Dark, Curious, Gothic, and Unusual Valentine Gifts | Valentine’s and Anti-Valentine Day | Human Hearts, Red Skulls, Black Roses, Skeleton Lovers, Gothic Literature, Horror Films, Tarot, Fetish | Dark Home Décor | Gothic Jewelry and Fashion | Me and Annabel Lee
How to make a DIY Tiered Raven Halloween Serving Tray | Goth it Yourself Edgar Allan Poe inspired server | Dessert Stand | Gothic Entertaining | The Raven Halloween Craft | Me and Annabel Lee Blog

Copyright © 2026 · Daily Dish Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

 

Loading Comments...
 

    We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.